Skip to content

Prop Firm Rules Explained: Targets, Drawdowns, Consistency

Share
Glass steps rising toward a floating screen with a glowing wave line, headline RISING FLOOR

Every funded-trading programme publishes a rulebook, and most traders read it the same way: scanning for the one number that could end the account. That reflex makes sense. It is also why accounts die to rules their owners had already read.

The problem is not the reading. It is the framing. A rulebook looks like a list of hurdles, so it gets treated like one — memorise the thresholds, avoid them, move on. But the thresholds are the output of the document, not its logic. Underneath, a rulebook is a risk contract, and every clause answers a question the firm has to answer before it puts capital behind a stranger on the internet.

There are four of those questions. Learn them, and any rulebook becomes readable in a single sitting.

Key Takeaways

  • A rulebook is a risk contract: every clause answers one of four questions about profit, loss, repeatability, or freedom.
  • A daily loss limit is a circuit breaker over a short window; the overall loss limit is the floor of the account and does not reset.
  • A limit measured on equity counts open positions too, so an unrealised drawdown is a real drawdown against it, right now.
  • Under a trailing overall limit, early profit is not a buffer but a new floor.
  • On CarrotFunding, there is no Best Day Rule and no consistency requirement on either challenge; the profit target and the equity limits are the only objectives.

Every rule answers a question about risk

The four questions are simple to state.

  • Can this trader make money at all?
  • How much can this trader lose before we stop?
  • Is the money repeatable, or was it one lucky afternoon?
  • What are we willing to let this trader do to get it?

Profit targets answer the first. Loss limits answer the second. Consistency rules answer the repeatability question. Everything else — time limits, style restrictions, news windows, weekend policy — answers the fourth.

Four families. That is the whole taxonomy. What follows is what each one actually measures, where the common misreadings live, and how the families collide in the moment that matters. Getting paid is a separate step with levers of its own, from eligibility to timing, set out in how prop firm payouts work.

Family one: the profit target

A profit target is the entry ticket. It is the firm asking whether you can produce a return at all, and it is the least interesting rule in any rulebook — because it is the only one you fail by standing still, and the only one you can approach at whatever speed you like.

What matters is what the target is measured against. A target expressed as a percentage of the starting balance is a moving goalpost that does not move: the number is set on day one and stays there, whatever happens to your equity in between. That is the version worth wanting, because it cannot drift away from you after a drawdown.

At Carrot the 2-Phase Challenge splits the target across two stages — Reach the Phase 1 (Evaluation) profit target of 5% to advance to Phase 2 (Verification). — where Phase 2 asks for 10%. The 1-Phase Challenge asks for the same 10%, once: Reach the 10% profit target while staying within both equity limits.

Why targets get split into phases

Two phases are not two hurdles. They are one hurdle, sampled twice.

A single evaluation can be passed by a trader who took one enormous swing and got lucky. A second phase asks the same question again, after the luck has had time to run out. That is the entire argument for the two-phase structure, and Carrot's own numbers show the trade in miniature: 5% and then 10% across two stages, against 10% once. The staged route asks for less at a time, and asks twice.

The one-phase structure makes the opposite trade. Fewer stages, faster route, and the firm compensates for the lost sample somewhere else in the document. Which brings us to the families that do the compensating.

Family two: the loss limits

This is where accounts actually end. Everything in this family is a variation on one question — how much are we willing to lose before we stop — and the variations matter enormously.

Daily loss and overall loss are different instruments

A daily loss limit is a circuit breaker. It exists to stop a bad session from becoming a bad week, and it is measured over a short window. An overall loss limit is the floor of the account. It does not reset. Touch it, and the evaluation is over.

Traders conflate them constantly, usually in the direction that hurts: treating the daily limit as if it were the floor, and discovering too late that a series of days well inside the daily limit has walked the account down to the overall one.

The measuring window is the part worth reading twice. At Carrot the Daily Loss Limit is a fixed amount, 3% or 4% of your starting balance, depending on the pair you choose, on both routes. It is measured from the highest closed balance of the last 24 hours, in a rolling window with no daily reset. On a venue that runs around the clock that is the honest fit: no boundary arrives while the market is still moving, and no second daily budget opens when your local trading day straddles midnight UTC. The reference moves only with your own best closed balance of the last day.

Equity or balance: the distinction that decides your day

A loss limit measured on balance counts closed trades. A loss limit measured on equity counts open ones too.

The difference is not academic. Under an equity-based limit, an unrealised drawdown on a position you fully intend to hold is a real drawdown, right now, against a real threshold. There is no waiting it out. Carrot states the arithmetic plainly — Balance plus unrealized P&L of open positions. — and the Daily Loss Limit is checked against equity, not balance.

If you take one thing from this section, take this.

Anchored or trailing

The last variable in this family is whether the overall loss limit stays where it started.

An anchored limit is set once against the starting balance and stays there. A trailing limit follows your equity upward as you profit, which means the floor rises underneath a winning account — protecting gains you have made, and tightening the room you have to give them back. Carrot's overall limit is anchored in the challenge: In the challenge it is static: it does not move, and open positions count toward it. On a funded account it becomes the Loss Floor, which rises with your best result, counting withdrawals, and stops at your Starting Balance. It sits at 3%, 6% or 8% of starting balance, chosen as a pair with the Daily Loss Limit: 3% / 3%, 6% / 3% or 8% / 4%. The figures for both routes are laid out side by side in the CarrotFunding Rulebook.

Anchored or trailing changes how you should behave after a good week. Under an anchored limit, early profit is a genuine buffer. Under a trailing one, it is not — it is a new floor.

Loss-limit choiceFirst optionSecond option
Daily or overallDaily: a circuit breaker over a short windowOverall: the floor of the account, which does not reset
Balance or equityBalance: counts closed tradesEquity: counts open positions too
Anchored or trailingAnchored: set once against the starting balanceTrailing: follows your equity upward as you profit

The repeatability family: consistency rules

The third question is the one traders resent most, and it is the most reasonable question in the document: was the money repeatable?

A firm about to allocate capital is not buying your best day. It is buying your distribution. A trader who made the target across many ordinary sessions and a trader who made it in one spectacular one have produced the same number and told the firm two completely different things about what happens next.

What a best-day rule actually measures

Consistency rules formalise that intuition as arithmetic. The mechanic is a ratio: take your total profit, remove your single best day, and ask how much of the result survives.

Carrot does not use one. The rulebook is explicit: There is no Best Day Rule and no consistency requirement on any CarrotFunding challenge — on the 2-Phase and the 1-Phase Challenge alike. Where a firm does run a best-day rule, two things about it are worth knowing before you plan around it.

The first is scope, which follows directly from the logic above: the case for such a rule is strongest on a single-phase route. A two-phase structure already samples you twice; it buys its repeatability evidence through the second phase instead of through a ratio.

The second is that a consistency rule can be built as a gate, not a trapdoor. Built that way, falling below the threshold does not end a challenge — the challenge continues. It holds progression until the distribution catches up, and the way it catches up is by trading normally, because every ordinary day you add makes your best day a smaller share of the total.

That reframing matters. A trader who reads a consistency rule as a threat trades scared. A trader who reads it as a ratio just keeps trading.

Family four: the freedom rules

The fourth family is defined by what a rulebook chooses not to restrict. Time limits, minimum trading days, holding-period rules, style prohibitions, news blackouts, weekend flat requirements — each one is a lever a firm can pull to reduce its own variance, and each one is paid for by the trader in flexibility.

These rules are easy to skim past, because an absence reads as nothing. It is not nothing. A minimum-days rule forces activity that a patient strategy would not otherwise take. A time limit converts a risk decision into a deadline decision. A news blackout removes exactly the sessions some strategies exist to trade.

The rules Carrot does not have

The rulebook states its position here in two sentences: Apart from your equity limits, the 15-second rule and the Forbidden Trading Practices, everything is up to you. No time restrictions, no style limits, no artificial barriers. No countdown. No minimum days. The 15-second rule it names is the one holding-time rule: Profits from positions held under 15 seconds do not count. Losses still do.

News trading is not fenced off either — the venue documentation states it directly: We don't restrict trading around news events - you can trade through them. And because Hyperliquid trades 24/7, there is no weekend flat rule to observe, because there is no weekend close to observe it against. We wrote about what that does to the rhythm of an evaluation in trading a challenge in a market that never closes.

Leverage is the dial that stays bounded: Standard: up to 5× per position, or Hyperliquid's maximum for that market if lower. That is a ceiling, not an instruction — and the number of challenges you may run in parallel has no ceiling at all: There is no limit on how many challenges you hold or pass, or on how many funded accounts you hold.

Where the families collide

Read individually, the four families are straightforward. The failures happen where they overlap, and two overlaps account for most of them.

Fees are part of your P&L

Trading costs are not a separate ledger that settles later. They land in the same P&L the loss limits are measured against — at Carrot, You pay standard Hyperliquid maker/taker fees with no markup, and those fees move your equity like any other debit.

For a high-frequency approach running close to a daily limit, that is not a rounding difference. Your costs and your risk budget draw on the same account, and a strategy sized as if they were separate is quietly overleveraged all day.

A breach is an event, not a negotiation

The last collision is procedural. A limit breach is evaluated by the system, at the moment of the touch, on equity that includes your open positions. It is not reviewed afterwards by someone weighing context.

Carrot's rulebook says so without softening it — Breaches are final. No resets and no exceptions. — and pairs it with a line from the same list, which is the part traders should actually price in: Your only loss is the challenge fee. A breach is final, and it is bounded. Both halves are true, and a rulebook that states the first without the second is telling you half of the contract.

How to read a rulebook quickly

The taxonomy collapses into six questions. Ask them of any rulebook, in this order.

  • Is the profit target measured on starting balance or on something that moves?
  • Is the daily limit measured on equity or on balance — and over what window?
  • Is the overall limit anchored to the start, or does it trail your high-water mark?
  • Is there a consistency rule, and does it gate progression or end the account?
  • Which freedoms are restricted — time, style, holding period, news, weekends?
  • What is the maximum I can lose, in currency, if every rule goes against me at once?

The last question is the one that puts the other five in proportion. Answer it first if you only have time for one.

Conclusion

Carrot publishes all of this in a single place rather than across a marketing page and a support article: the full parameter set for both routes is in the CarrotFunding Rulebook, the route from evaluation to a funded account is documented in how the challenge process works, and the phase-by-phase specifics live in the evaluation and verification account documentation.

Read the rulebook as a contract, not a warning label. The rules are not there to catch you out — they are the firm telling you, in advance and in writing, exactly what it is buying.

FAQ

Is a consistency rule just another kind of loss limit?

No. A loss limit measures how much you lose; a consistency rule measures how your profit is spread across days. A large winning day is no problem for a loss limit, yet under a best-day rule it can hold progression until enough ordinary days reduce its share of the total. One family protects the firm's capital, the other tests whether your result is repeatable.

What happens to the target and the loss limits once the account is funded?

On CarrotFunding, a funded account keeps the same starting balance, the profit target is removed and payouts become available, and the core risk rules remain in place. The first family drops away; the loss limits do not. That is the practical reason to learn them properly during the challenge: they stay with the account once the target is gone.

Does higher leverage change the loss limits?

On CarrotFunding, no. You can choose any leverage up to the limit, and using the maximum is never required, but the limits are measured on equity either way. What leverage changes is how fast a price move reaches them: a larger position moves equity further for the same change in price, so the same limit arrives sooner.

Can a breached challenge be restarted?

On CarrotFunding, a breached account is not restarted, and the rulebook says: Challenge fees are non-refundable, regardless of outcome, with one exception: if you pass but cannot complete identity verification for reasons outside your control, and an alternative check also fails, we refund the fee. Starting again means starting a new challenge. There is no limit on how many challenges you hold or pass, or on how many funded accounts you hold. So a breach closes that one account, not your route into the programme.

Contents
Topics

92 articles in total

Ready to trade with our capital?

Pass the evaluation and trade funded on a prop firm built by traders, for traders.

Get Funded

More Insights

Education

What Is MEV? Who Sees Your Transaction Before It Lands

MEV is the value someone can earn by choosing the order of transactions before they land in a block. Here is where your transaction waits, how front-running, sandwiches and back-running work, what changes between pools and order books, and why a public order is not the same as a fair one.

9 min read